WASHINGTON — Senate Commerce Committee Chair Ted Cruz (R-TX) began a high-stakes committee meeting Wednesday meant to confirm President Donald Trump’s nominee to the Federal Communications Commission with a starkly lopsided dais. To his right sat all 14 Republican members of the panel, including Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-SD). To his left were about a dozen empty chairs, as every single Democratic member of the panel chose to stage a complete boycott of the proceedings. Cruz opened the session by telling reporters and committee members that he had learned just the night before that Democrats intended to orchestrate the boycott. However, Democrats countered that they had repeatedly raised their deep concerns with committee leadership about the unprecedented nature of advancing a Republican FCC nominee without a simultaneous Democratic nomination to preserve historical balance at the independent agency. Read Also: I Made an AI Digital Twin of Myself at Synthesia, and It’s the Final Boss of Tech Journalism Google Expands Experimental AI App ‘Dreambeans’ to India in First International Rollout "The administration has shown it’s willing to move Democrats," Cruz said during the meeting, pointing to parallel Senate votes scheduled on bipartisan pairs of nominations to other independent federal entities, such as the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the Securities and Exchange Commission. Cruz added that even though the Supreme Court recently confirmed the executive branch’s power to do so, Trump has not yet moved to fire any sitting Democrats from the FCC, a sharp contrast to his aggressive actions at the Federal Trade Commission, where Democratic commissioners were ousted. "This is an ordinary nomination to fill a vacancy previously held by someone in the same party," Cruz insisted, attempting to frame the nomination as routine business. However, in statements, press releases, and remarks delivered to reporters outside the committee room before and during the markup, Democrats argued that the entire confirmation process has been anything but normal. Historically, Senate committees have often advanced nominations to historically independent regulatory agencies in balanced, bipartisan pairs to prevent one political party from capturing total regulatory control. Advancing Danielle Thumann Severs, who currently serves as senior counsel to FCC Chair Brendan Carr, to become a full commissioner at the agency would tilt the political balance of the FCC to four total members: three Republicans and only one Democrat, Anna Gomez. While Gomez’s official term has technically expired, she is legally permitted to remain on the commission through next year unless she is formally replaced by the administration. Despite this provision, congressional Democrats harbor deep fears that by confirming a third Republican to the FCC, Trump might finally move to fire Gomez, because the agency would no longer require her physical presence to establish a quorum to vote on major regulatory actions and key policy items. Prior to the vote, Democrats formally asked for Thumann’s confirmation process to be withheld until her nomination could be properly paired with a Democratic nomination. One straightforward way to achieve this equilibrium would be for the White House to simply renominate Gomez. Yet, to date, the president has failed to offer any Democratic nominees for the commission. Democrats emphasized that they made their objections and procedural concerns abundantly clear to Cruz and the committee majority ahead of time. "This is not a problem we created, but a problem that the White House can solve," Democratic lawmakers asserted in joint statements. The White House did not immediately respond to multiple requests for comment regarding the nomination strategy or the Democratic demands. Beyond the broader procedural objections regarding agency balance, Democrats voiced serious concerns about Thumann’s recent work history as an adviser to Carr, specifically questioning whether she had been entirely truthful under oath regarding the specific regulatory matters she handled during her tenure. In a formal letter urging Cruz to delay her confirmation vote, Sen. Ben Ray Luján (D-NM) detailed a series of alarming discrepancies. During her November 10 confirmation hearing, where Thumann answered direct questions from committee members, she testified under oath that she had "not worked with the Chairman on any media-related issues," Luján noted in his letter. However, official internal documents and communications obtained via a Freedom of Information Act request paint a vastly different picture. The records show that Thumann was actively "looped in" on various high-profile media matters. According to Luján’s letter, she "helped draft Skydance’s commitments that facilitated the FCC’s approval of the Skydance-Paramount merger." Furthermore, the documents indicate that "she also played a role in processing informal complaints related to CBS 60 Minutes’ alleged news distortion and she apparently orchestrated the Commission’s response to consumers regarding the Jimmy Kimmel controversy." The FCC did not immediately respond to requests for comment regarding these specific document disclosures. Even committee Republicans have previously acknowledged unease surrounding the agency’s actions under Carr’s leadership. Even Cruz himself had admitted concerns with Carr’s controversial handling of late-night host Jimmy Kimmel’s comments in the aftermath of the killing of conservative activist Charlie Kirk. However, at Wednesday’s meeting, Cruz struck a much more conciliatory tone regarding the nominee, stating that he "emphatically agree[s]" that Thumann had successfully resolved any lingering worries about those incidents during the vetting process. Cruz added that his proposed JAWBONE Act, which the Commerce Committee previously passed, could directly address potential First Amendment violations committed by government agencies of any political affiliation. The legislation would establish a legal framework allowing individuals to sue government officials if they illegally attempt to compel social media or broadcast companies to remove or censor lawful speech. Sen. Jerry Moran (R-KS), who had also expressed serious concern over the Kimmel incident and Carr’s involvement, echoed Cruz’s sentiment. Moran stated that he found Thumann’s explanations and responses on the subject to be "comforting." Moran noted that he had engaged in a direct phone call with Thumann earlier that very morning, during which he expressed his "serious interest in how the FCC protects and promotes free speech, including free speech on broadcast." According to Moran, Thumann "was able to satisfy me once again in her answers, including an explanation for her role at the FCC and her lack of engagement on this type of issue as the FCC made decisions." Speaking forcefully to reporters outside of the committee hearing room ahead of the morning meeting, Luján leveled direct accusations against the nominee, claiming that Thumann had deliberately lied to the committee during her confirmation hearings. "The questions that I have is if she was lying about this, what else is she lying about and what else is she hiding?" Luján asked rhetorically. Luján added that he wants both Thumann and FCC Chair Brendan Carr to appear before the Commerce Committee by the end of the year to answer a comprehensive round of lawmaker questions under oath. When asked by reporters if he would support utilizing the committee’s aggressive subpoena power, or even pursuing potential impeachment proceedings against Carr if Democrats regain congressional power next year, Luján did not rule out extreme measures. He remarked that his past vote to confirm Carr as a commissioner during the administration of President Joe Biden ranks among his biggest personal regrets in public office. While he expressed hope that Carr will choose to testify voluntarily, Luján emphasized that "everything should be on the table here to be able to get answers for the American people." When the hearing finally reached the moment of decision, and it was time to vote on whether to advance Thumann’s nomination to the final stage of a full vote on the Senate floor, all 15 Republican committee members present cast their votes as "aye." The unanimous Republican support provided Thumann with enough votes for her nomination to successfully clear the committee and advance to the Senate floor, where it is widely expected to pass strictly along party lines once leadership officially schedules the floor vote. As the vote concluded, the committee clerk read aloud the names of the 13 Democratic committee members whose seats remained entirely empty throughout the proceedings. There was no response from the left side of the dais. Post navigation Two British Hackers Face Long Prison Sentences for Roles in Notorious Cybercriminal Syndicates