The Home Assistant subreddit is frequently flooded with screenshots of elaborate user dashboards. Long before the era of conversational "vibe-coding," enthusiasts loved showing off how they organized their automated lives. However, the prevalence of these showcases has exploded recently, largely because users can now simply ask an AI chatbot to design and build an interface for them. The downside to this wave of AI-generated dashboards is that they almost all look identical. While they are often visually polished, they tend to be overly cluttered, lacking in genuine user-friendliness, and bearing that unmistakable aesthetic signature common to automated AI creations. Determined to see if modern artificial intelligence could break free from this homogenization, smart home veteran and tech journalist Adam Davidson set out to test whether ChatGPT’s Codex could build a Home Assistant dashboard that was genuinely different. After a grueling process of trial and error, that is precisely what happened. Read Also: Beyond the Basic Switch: Unlocking the Bizarre and Unexpected Potential of Old Wi-Fi Routers Breathing New Life Into Aging Hardware: How Linux Turns Old PCs Into Essential Home Infrastructure Codex Started by Focusing on What It Thought Mattered To bridge the gap between advanced language models and local automation hardware, Davidson utilized the Home Assistant Model Context Protocol (MCP) tool. This protocol permits external AI systems to read and write directly to a Home Assistant server. Exposing a smart home network to a cloud-based processing tool presents obvious security and privacy considerations, meaning users must weigh carefully what data they are willing to share. For the purposes of this experiment, Davidson granted Codex fairly broad access to his home network, enabling the system to examine connected devices, active entities, existing automations, and historical logs. His prompt to the AI was straightforward: analyze the smart home environment, identify devices that required frequent manual interaction, and design a dashboard featuring complete creative freedom. The primary directive was to avoid the cookie-cutter design patterns dominating social media forums like Reddit. The initial result, however, was disappointing. Codex quickly located an elaborate set of automations designed to track and mitigate the risk of mold—a persistent hazard in older, damp residential properties. Rather than distributing focus across the entire household, the AI’s first attempt produced a fairly generic dashboard dominated entirely by a massive section dedicated to mold risk, leaving little room for anything else. The Second and Third Attempts Weren’t Much Better Recognizing the flaws in the first iteration, Davidson explained to Codex that the design was overly fixated on a single aspect of the home while retaining its generic appearance. The AI attempted a second revision, but the output shifted to displaying upcoming stages of various background automations—information that offered little practical utility for daily living. The third attempt proved slightly more intriguing. Codex integrated the two controls Davidson used most frequently on typical evenings—his bedside lamp and his electric blanket—as permanent interface elements, alongside a compiled list of outstanding household issues requiring attention. While this design drifted away from a traditional dashboard concept and leaned more toward an information status screen, it at least introduced a distinct visual layout. The Fourth Attempt Was at Least a Little Different Still unsatisfied with a layout primarily composed of standard interface widgets, Davidson provided more targeted feedback. He instructed Codex to invent an original, innovative method for presenting controls and data, emphasizing that the final product must not rely on a standard collection of basic button cards. In response, Codex shifted its approach by treating the smart home camera feed as if it were viewed through a physical camera shutter. Other home domains, such as lighting, heating, and audio systems, were conceptualized as distinct lenses capable of altering the controls displayed on the screen. Although this concept introduced a novel visual theme, it remained fundamentally a traditional collection of dashboard controls wrapped in a stylistic veneer. It still failed to provide the genuinely fresh user experience Davidson was looking for. The Final Dashboard Was Something Genuinely New Nearing the limits of his Codex plan usage, Davidson decided to give the AI one final opportunity. He clarified that previous iterations were merely themed button collections and challenged the model to conceive an interaction model that had never been seen before. The resulting dashboard surprised even a long-time smart home automation enthusiast. While other developers may have independently explored similar concepts, the design introduced a routing mechanism where users control devices by dragging a visual line from a room to a device, and finally to an action. Initiating a route in the study, for example, populates a curated list of devices located within that specific space. Dragging the line through a specific device, such as a smart light bulb, dynamically updates an action column with contextual commands like turning the device off, dimming it to a specific percentage, or opening a comprehensive settings panel. The available commands adapt intelligently based on the current state of the hardware. The entire interaction relies on drawing directional paths using a computer mouse, trackpad, or a finger on a mobile touchscreen. While the implementation required persistent effort and detailed prompting, Codex successfully delivered an interface that deviated sharply from conventional grid layouts, even if its long-term utility in daily life remains to be seen. AI Tools Can Do a Lot, But They’re Still Not Great at Original Ideas This extensive experiment highlights a broader limitation common to current artificial intelligence systems. While conversational chatbots and coding agents excel at technical implementation, software execution, and layout generation, they struggle significantly with genuine conceptual originality. This underlying constraint explains why so many automated smart home dashboards and customized television launchers share identical design blueprints across online communities. When a truly novel design approach is required, human ingenuity remains essential. Post navigation Clippy Is Back: How Open-Source AI Brought Microsoft’s Iconic Paperclip to Windows 11