In the modern digital economy, keeping track of recurring payments has become a frustrating chore for many consumers. From forgotten free trials requiring upfront credit card details to monthly subscriptions for tools used only once, unexpected charges are an all-too-common annoyance. While various third-party applications exist to monitor these expenses, many users are reluctant to download yet another paid app or hand over sensitive financial data to an unfamiliar service.

I asked Gemini and Claude to build a no-code subscription tracker

Faced with this exact dilemma, one tech journalist decided to bypass traditional software entirely, turning instead to modern generative artificial intelligence to engineer a custom, lightweight solution. By tasking Google’s Gemini and Anthropic’s Claude with building a dedicated subscription tracker from scratch, a fascinating comparative test unfolded, revealing distinct differences in how leading AI models approach coding, user experience, and reliability.

The initial goal was straightforward: design a centralized web-based tool capable of calculating monthly and yearly spending, flagging any services scheduled to renew within a seven-day window, and retaining user modifications locally. Without any prior coding expertise, the project relied purely on natural language prompting, utilizing sample subscription data to test the foundational logic of both applications.

I asked Gemini and Claude to build a no-code subscription tracker

Both Chatbots Aced

the Build on the First Try

The experiment began by engaging Gemini’s powerful Argon model, leveraging its advanced capabilities inside Google’s Canvas workspace. Furnished with a single comprehensive prompt detailing all desired features, Gemini produced a fully functioning prototype almost immediately. Beyond meeting the basic requirements, the model proactively incorporated several sophisticated additions, including a dynamic search bar, sorting menus, dedicated filters for monthly and yearly plans, individual "Roll to Next Cycle" buttons for each item, and a visual spending breakdown bar. Gemini even christened the application "SubPulse," adding a polished touch to the experimental software.

I asked Gemini and Claude to build a no-code subscription tracker

Concurrently, Anthropic’s Claude was given the exact same prompt and sample dataset. Claude’s approach was notably more minimalist, focusing strictly on core functionality without unnecessary visual flourishes. However, Claude included an intelligent automatic rollover feature unprompted, ensuring that past-due renewal dates would automatically shift forward to the next billing cycle.

When tested initially, both AI-generated applications performed admirably. The sample data displayed correctly, underlying financial calculations were accurate, and interactive elements such as adding, editing, and deleting entries functioned smoothly. At this early stage, the primary distinctions lay in Gemini’s broader array of features and aesthetic choices, leaving the creator impressed with both outputs.

I asked Gemini and Claude to build a no-code subscription tracker

A Small Change Broke One of the Builds

Encouraged by the initial success, the project moved to a secondary phase: implementing iterative improvements. Both chatbots were asked to integrate a dark mode toggle and a dedicated notes field for each subscription entry to enhance overall utility.

While Claude processed the request seamlessly, Gemini encountered a critical failure. Upon opening the updated Gemini build, the user was greeted by a completely blank page. Although the underlying code remained intact within the chat interface, the application’s preview window had broken entirely. Subsequent attempts to troubleshoot the issue—including asking Gemini to find and remove stray code, as well as initiating entirely new chat sessions to rebuild the app from scratch—yielded the same frustrating result. The previously robust Gemini application had become unusable, forcing the project creator to abandon that particular iteration.

I asked Gemini and Claude to build a no-code subscription tracker

Claude, by contrast, breezed through the modifications without missing a beat. The updated build rendered correctly, retained all data modifications, and operated smoothly without destabilizing the application environment.

One Tracker Looks Better on My Home Screen

A functional application is of little practical use if it remains buried deep within a chat history interface. To ensure everyday usability, both web-based builds needed a permanent, easily accessible home on a mobile device running Android.

I asked Gemini and Claude to build a no-code subscription tracker

Using Chrome, shortcuts were generated for both the Claude and Gemini trackers, allowing them to be pinned directly to the phone’s home screen. This final phase of testing ultimately solidified Claude’s victory. Claude’s application shortcut featured a clean, unique icon that integrated seamlessly into the device’s interface, making the tracker feel like a standalone native application rather than a browser-based extension of an AI chat window. Furthermore, Claude’s web interface scaled properly to fill the entire screen.

Gemini’s deployed version, conversely, presented several user experience hurdles. The home screen shortcut defaulted to a generic, uninspired letter "G" icon, failing to provide visual distinction. When launched, the web preview neglected to utilize the full height of the display, leaving an empty, wasted quarter of screen space at the top. Compounding the issue, data changes made on the web version of the Gemini tracker failed to sync back to the original build inside the Gemini mobile application.

I asked Gemini and Claude to build a no-code subscription tracker

I’m Keeping Claude’s Tracker

Despite initial enthusiasm for Gemini’s feature-rich interface and appealing aesthetic design, technical instability and interface quirks ultimately turned the tide. Claude’s reliable code generation, seamless update process, superior mobile integration, and consistent synchronization made it the clear winner for a permanent daily tool.

As artificial intelligence continues to lower the barrier for custom software development, experiments like this highlight both the immense potential of no-code generation and the current variance in reliability among top-tier models. For users seeking to regain control over recurring financial commitments without downloading commercial bloatware, leveraging generative AI to build bespoke trackers is a viable—if occasionally unpredictable—path forward.