Meta has been hit with a substantial regulatory penalty in Europe, highlighting ongoing tensions between tech giants and regional privacy watchdogs. The Italian data protection authority, known as the Garante, levied a fine of €805 million against Meta over a specific Facebook for Android feature that automatically suggests photos and videos from users’ personal phone galleries for them to post on the platform. The regulatory enforcement action underscores mounting scrutiny regarding how major social media applications handle device-level permissions and access sensitive user archives without obtaining distinct, unambiguous consent.

According to the Garante’s findings, the controversial feature was enabled by default upon installation or updates, allowing the Facebook application to access Italian users’ private photos, videos, and associated metadata without requiring explicit, separate authorization. Following the regulatory ruling, Meta has been granted a strict window of 60 days to switch the feature off by default for all affected users, including individuals who had previously granted the application broader gallery access. Furthermore, the company must establish a separate mechanism to request proper, informed consent if users wish to opt into the feature voluntarily.

In response to the penalty, a spokesperson for Meta announced that the company plans to appeal the decision, characterizing the multi-million-euro fine as "disproportionate" given the technical design and functionality of the application.

The investigation into Meta’s practices began following a formal complaint filed on July 11, 2025, by the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection organization based in Bolzano, Italy. In the wake of the initial complaint, the consumer group published advisory notices urging individuals to manually switch off gallery suggestion settings within the Facebook application and to carefully review what access and device permissions the platform held on their smartphones. This grassroots consumer concern eventually catalyzed the Garante’s comprehensive technical analysis and formal regulatory inquiry.

Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook's Android Gallery Access Without Explicit Consent

During its investigation, the Italian privacy authority discovered that the Facebook application requested gallery access through a single, all-encompassing permission prompt that covered the entire app framework alongside several distinct functions serving entirely different operational purposes. The authority noted that while a general notice regarding the enablement of secondary features might appear during the setup process, it completely failed to make it transparent or clear to everyday users that they were simultaneously enabling automated gallery suggestions and continuous background scanning of their media libraries.

When fully granted, a broad permission of this nature enables the application to read a smartphone’s entire photo archive on an ongoing, continuous basis. The Garante emphasized that under this opaque arrangement, neither the individual user nor the regulatory authority has any practical way to verify which specific pieces of personal information are actually accessed, processed, or utilized by the platform.

The regulatory body determined that these practices constituted a direct breach of Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, which effectively transposes the European Union’s ePrivacy Directive into national Italian legislation. Under this legal framework, a user’s personal smartphone or mobile device is legally recognized as an extension of their private personal life. Consequently, any form of access to data stored locally on the device—regardless of whether that data is subsequently transmitted elsewhere or whether tangible harm can be demonstrated—requires explicit, free, and fully informed consent from the owner.

The Garante’s official enforcement order dictates precise corrective actions that Meta must implement within the stipulated 60-day timeframe. If the corporation fails to comply and misses the deadline, the feature must remain permanently switched off for any individual who has not provided valid, independent consent.

Meta has defended its platform architecture, pointing out that the feature strictly operates only after users authorize device-level permissions through their operating system settings, and noting that these permissions can be altered or revoked by the user at any point within their device configurations. Additionally, the company maintained throughout the proceedings that Ireland’s Data Protection Commission—acting as its lead supervisory authority under the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation—should have handled the case instead of the Italian watchdog. However, the Garante firmly rejected this argument, establishing that the specific ePrivacy rules governing local device storage do not fall under the purview of the GDPR’s centralized one-stop-shop mechanism.

Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook's Android Gallery Access Without Explicit Consent

During the course of the investigation, regulatory authorities also examined whether the harvested gallery content was being utilized to train artificial intelligence models. Meta has consistently denied using the scraped gallery data for AI training purposes. Nevertheless, the Garante indicated that it may independently examine a newer feature launched earlier in the year that allows certain gallery content to be processed within cloud environments.

The feature at the center of the dispute has been actively available to Android users since 2023, with the Garante launching its formal investigation in July 2025 utilizing internal technical experts. In calculating the final monetary penalty, the Italian authority took several aggravating and mitigating factors into account. The fine equates to approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global annual revenue. In arriving at this figure, the regulator weighed the vast scale of the infringement, which impacted approximately 20 million Android users across Italy, as well as the prolonged duration of the violation. The breach remains actively ongoing for individuals who have failed to update their mobile application, as well as those who previously granted blanket permissions.

Other contributing factors considered by the authority included a prior 2019 regulatory decision against the company and what the agency characterized as limited cooperation during the investigative phases. Conversely, modifications and adjustments that Meta implemented following the initial consumer complaint were counted in the company’s favor, though the regulator ultimately judged these remedial changes to be late and restricted solely to users who kept their applications updated.